The Deadliest and Safest Cities to Drive In

America's 50 largest cities ranked by how dangerous they are to drive in. Memphis is the most dangerous city to drive in. Minneapolis is the safest city for driving.

How it was measured

We measured car and truck occupant deaths per 100 million miles driven to control for population density and the number of drivers on the road.

Each city is defined by its 2020 Census urban area, not by strict city bounds. Vehicle fatalities are from NHTSA FARS (2021–2024); traffic volume is from FHWA's 2024 highway inventory. Pedestrians, cyclists, and motorcyclists are not included.

Cities ranked by deaths per 100M miles driven
95% confidence intervals. Red/blue cities significantly deviate from the urban average.

The 5 deadliest

1. Memphis — 1.78

Memphis is three times the urban average and more than twice the next city. Speeding is a major problem in Memphis, with local authorities undertaking a decade-long effort to crack down on speeding. Memphis also has many wide, fast arterial roads that are typically more dangerous than other road types. Recent efforts against reckless driving have led to a measurable reduction in fatalities in 2025.

Memphis road risk map
Memphis: roads colored by TripRisk model rate, dots are fatal crashes 2021–24.

2. Louisville — 0.80

Louisville's city streets are at about 1.5× the urban street average.

Louisville road risk map
Louisville

3. St. Louis — 0.77

Safe-ish freeways (0.45), but the streets are among the highest outside Memphis.

St. Louis road risk map
St. Louis

4. Nashville — 0.73

The fastest rising fatality rate: 27th before the pandemic, 4th now.

Nashville road risk map
Nashville

5. Kansas City — 0.70

Kansas City road risk map
Kansas City

The 5 safest

50. Minneapolis–St. Paul — 0.29

The safest big city to drive in.

Minneapolis–St. Paul road risk map
Minneapolis–St. Paul

49. Boston — 0.31

Low on both freeways (0.24) and streets (0.38).

Boston road risk map
Boston

48. San Jose — 0.31

The only big city where city streets are no deadlier than its freeways.

San Jose road risk map
San Jose

47. San Francisco–Oakland — 0.35

San Francisco–Oakland road risk map
San Francisco–Oakland

46. New York — 0.36

Despite 300 occupant deaths a year, New York's huge volume of driving makes it among the safest in the country.

New York road risk map
New York

Full ranking

RankCityOverallFreewaysCity streetsDeaths/yr
1Memphis1.780.722.58156
2Louisville0.800.521.1563
3St. Louis0.770.451.23142
4Nashville0.730.401.1781
5Kansas City0.700.421.1294
6Phoenix0.690.310.97216
7Riverside–San Bernardino0.670.411.11128
8Milwaukee0.660.190.9966
9Jacksonville0.660.410.9368
10Atlanta0.640.440.85264
11Chicago0.640.400.81320
12Richmond0.630.570.7158
13Miami–Fort Lauderdale0.630.370.83288
14Philadelphia0.600.380.77191
15Denver0.600.350.85104
16Dallas–Fort Worth0.600.460.78314
17Hartford0.590.520.6847
18Indianapolis0.590.300.8287
19Houston0.580.320.88280
20Las Vegas0.580.220.8377
21Tampa–St. Petersburg0.580.390.66123
22Detroit0.570.370.72160
23Oklahoma City0.560.390.7642
24New Orleans0.550.510.5934
25Cleveland0.550.380.7772
26San Antonio0.550.350.8187
27Sacramento0.540.370.7168
28Seattle0.540.310.80121
29Columbus0.530.320.7963
30Virginia Beach–Norfolk0.530.310.7251
31Charlotte0.520.410.6259
32Orlando0.510.310.6684
33Austin0.490.320.6366
34Cincinnati0.480.240.7562
35Baltimore0.470.280.7481
36Pittsburgh0.470.280.5845
37Raleigh0.450.260.6040
38Portland0.440.200.6455
39Los Angeles0.420.310.52349
40Providence0.410.300.5536
41Washington DC0.410.290.52140
42Bridgeport–Stamford0.410.330.5327
43Buffalo0.400.250.5022
44Salt Lake City0.390.180.5834
45San Diego0.380.310.5088
46New York0.360.270.46300
47San Francisco–Oakland0.350.310.4168
48San Jose0.310.330.3034
49Boston0.310.240.3897
50Minneapolis–St. Paul0.290.150.4665

Rates are occupant deaths per 100 million vehicle-miles. Sources: NHTSA FARS 2021–2024, FHWA HPMS 2024, US Census 2020 urban areas.